« "$2 Million Tax Hit" Follow Up | Main | The value(?) of PG rankings »

"$2 Million Tax Hit" 

With the trade between the Marlins & Blue Jays, the deal I negotiated with the Marlins in 2004 for Carlos Delgado looks even better. When the Marlins refused to include a “no trade” clause, I insisted that they agree to unique language that gave Carlos some protection in the event of a trade.

The deal I negotiated contained a guarantee that if he was traded to a team that resided in a state that had a state income tax, the team he was traded to would “make him whole”. In other words he would net out the same amount he would have received had he remained in Florida, a state with NO state income tax. This had NEVER been done in MLB before... and to the best of my knowledge, has not been done by ANYONE since.

BTW, the amount Delgado saved on a contract signed EIGHT years ago is roughly $2,269,500. If you factor in inflation, both inflation in the US dollar  approximately 25%

http://www.usinflationcalculator.com/inflation/historical-inflation-rates/

AND 40% increase in Average MLB salary,  that figure would increase SIGNIFICANTLY... probably equal to a NET value to Carlos of more than $4 million in 2013 dollars.

The Agents for Jose’ Reyes (Peter Greenberg, now part of Legacy Group), Mark Buehrle (CAA Jeff Berry), Josh Johnson (Sosnick/Cobbe), Emilio Bonifacio (Paul Kinzer who was recently fired from Wasserman Sports), John Buck (Aces) whose companies collectively employ well over 100 Agents and represent more than 1500 Players didn’t protect their clients as well as I protected Delgado. And, as you can see from the article below, they will literally pay a heavy price for being represented by Agents who do a better job of recruiting Players than they do of representing them.

http://www.forbes.com/sites/kurtbadenhausen/2012/11/14/traded-marlins-players-will-take-2-million-tax-hit-in-canada/ 

Kurt Badenhausen, Forbes Staff

I cover sports business with rare dip in education & local economies

 11/14/2012 @ 12:38PM |1,199 views

Traded Marlins Players Will Take $2 Million Tax Hit In Canada

This is a guest post from K. Sean Packard, CPA, who is the Director of Tax at OFS where he specializes in tax planning and the preparation of tax returns for professional athletes. He can be reached on Twitter at @AthleteTax and atsean.packard@ofswealth.com.

The Miami Marlins are set to trade Jose Reyes, Josh Johnson, Mark Buehrle, John Buck and Emilio Bonifacio to the Toronto Blue Jays in exchange for Yunel Escobar and a handful of prospects. With a combined $40+ million due to these players in 2013, the Marlins’ motivation for this move is to cut payroll for a club that underperformed in 2012. If the trade is approved by the commissioner, the players involved face significant tax consequences.

Being traded from the Marlins to the Blue Jays will cost Johnson nearly $600,000 per year. Reyes and Buehrle will lose similar amounts. Combined the five players will face a higher tax bill of roughly $2 million.

Players across all sports are aware of the tax consequences of signing with a Canadian team, which is why high-priced free agents view the Blue Jays and Raptors with a wary eye when considering their options. It is difficult for these teams to compete on a level playing field with other teams in their respective sports.

Tax rates in Canada are significantly higher than in the U.S., especially for players in Florida, which does not have a state income tax. Under current law, the highest tax rate in the US in 2013 will be 40.5% (39.6% assuming the Bush tax cuts are not extended plus 0.9% Medicare surtax on high earners). Ontario recently increased its highest provincial tax rate to 18.97%. When combined with Canada’s 29% federal rate, players will pay 47.97% income tax in 2013.

The highest paid player involved in the trade was Josh Johnson, who will earn $13.75 million in 2013 (Buehrle is due $11 million and Reyes $10 million). Because Johnson will likely not spend over 183 days in Canada in a given year, he will file there as a non-resident. When taking into account spring training and road games, about 40% ($5.5 million) of his income will be taxable in Canada, resulting in roughly $2.6 million in Canadian taxes. His tax on this income in the U.S. would be roughly $2.2 million, a difference of $400,000 in 2013.

To further exacerbate the players’ tax problem, Canada does not allow deductions for common baseball expenses, which are deductible in the US. These include:

  • Agent Fees – Typically 4% to 5% of a player’s salary.
  • Clubhouse Dues – Tips paid to clubhouse managers (clubbies) at home and on the road. Clubbies set up the players’ lockers before each game, lay out the pre- and post-game spread, adjust players’ equipment and provide any other service the player may need. It is not uncommon for a player to pay $20,000 to $50,000 in clubhouse dues in a season. Typically the higher earners pay the most.
  • Training Expenses – Athletes utilize specialized trainers to maintain their fitness in the offseason, especially as spring training approaches.

Canada and the U.S. both allow deductions for union dues.

As for Johnson, if Canada allowed deductions for baseball expenses, he would deduct 40% of those expenses. Assuming he pays a 5% agent’s fee, $50,000 in clubhouse dues and $10,000 in offseason training in 2013, he would have $300,000 in deductions, resulting in nearly $150,000 of tax savings he will not receive.

Johnson is allowed some relief. Because he is U.S. citizen/resident, he will receive a credit for taxes paid in Canada. But this credit cannot exceed the taxes paid in the U.S. on the same income and does not include the 0.9% Medicare surtax. Further, Johnson must reduce his baseball income by the allocatable portion of his baseball expenses (40%) even though they are not deductible in Canada. This reduces his foreign tax credit to $2.06 million, or nearly $600,000 below what he paid.

While the unused foreign tax credit can be applied to future years, it is unlikely that Mr. Johnson will ever see the majority of it. In order to receive any of the credit back in future years, he would have to sign his next contract with—or be traded to—an American League team who plays games in Canada, preferably an American League East team who plays ten games a year there. If he plays games in Canada for another team, he can treat the earnings from those games as foreign earnings for purposes of the credit carryover. Due to the tax treaty between the U.S. and Canada, income from visiting players is not taxable in Canada.

 

References (38)

References allow you to track sources for this article, as well as articles that were written in response to this article.
  • Response
    "$2 Million Tax Hit" - David's Blog - Taurus Sports Associates
  • Response
    "$2 Million Tax Hit" - David's Blog - Taurus Sports Associates
  • Response
    "$2 Million Tax Hit"  - David's Blog - Taurus Sports Associates
  • Response
    Response: petuerey online
    Largo Color de la chaqueta abajo de helado, un diseño de falda floja, gastada en posesión de carne era colores finos, suaves y encantadoras, cuello de peluche y puños adornados, es cálido y elegante. Con medias blancas y botas negras que se desgasten, revela un temperamento apacible.
  • Response
    "$2 Million Tax Hit" - David's Blog - Taurus Sports Associates
  • Response
    Response: leather coats
  • Response
    How do I check to get these sports tips and tricks?
  • Response
    The Miami Marlins are set to trade Jose Reyes, Josh Johnson, Mark Buehrle, John Buck and Emilio Bonifacio to the Toronto Blue Jays in exchange for Yunel Escobar and a handful of prospects.
  • Response
    Response: texas seo
    "$2 Million Tax Hit" - David's Blog - Taurus Sports Associates
  • Response
    "$2 Million Tax Hit" - David's Blog - Taurus Sports Associates
  • Response
    Response: more info
    "$2 Million Tax Hit" - David's Blog - Taurus Sports Associates
  • Response
    "$2 Million Tax Hit" - David's Blog - Taurus Sports Associates
  • Response
    "$2 Million Tax Hit" - David's Blog - Taurus Sports Associates
  • Response
    "$2 Million Tax Hit" - David's Blog - Taurus Sports Associates
  • Response
    "$2 Million Tax Hit" - David's Blog - Taurus Sports Associates
  • Response
    Response: comment-19843
    "$2 Million Tax Hit" - David's Blog - Taurus Sports Associates
  • Response
    "$2 Million Tax Hit" - David's Blog - Taurus Sports Associates
  • Response
    "$2 Million Tax Hit" - David's Blog - Taurus Sports Associates
  • Response
    Response: excessive sweating
    "$2 Million Tax Hit" - David's Blog - Taurus Sports Associates
  • Response
    "$2 Million Tax Hit" - David's Blog - Taurus Sports Associates
  • Response
    "$2 Million Tax Hit" - David's Blog - Taurus Sports Associates
  • Response
    The share I negotiated contained a insure that if he was traded to a club that resided in a enunciate that had a posture receipts impost, the club he was traded to would fashion him absolute. In further proverbs he would chic away the alike bulk he would bear received had ...
  • Response
    Response: www.jocurieroi.eu
    "$2 Million Tax Hit" - David's Blog - Taurus Sports Associates
  • Response
    Response: M93687
     ロシアの電子新聞ニュータイムスは21日 M91994 、プーチン大統領の政敵で突然釈放されベルリンに出国した元石油大手社長ホドルコフスキー氏(50)との会見映像の一部を公開した。同氏は10年に及んだ服役期間中、親類らと長時間の面会が許されたのは「4年間だけだった」と述べ、外部との接触を厳しく制限されていた実態を明らかにした,M91994。同氏の肉声が伝えられるのは釈放後初めて。  同氏は黒いシャツとジーンズのくつろいだ服装で、笑顔で質問に答えた。ニュータイムスは釈放後初めてのインタビューだとしている。イ
  • Response
    "$2 Million Tax Hit" - David's Blog - Taurus Sports Associates
  • Response
    Response: PVC hoses
    According to reports ABS pipes , a PVC wire and cable i PVC hoses ndustry insiders Liu told reporters that,ABS pipes, driven by the interests of scrap, recycling of waste pla PVC Pipes stics production and processing of PVC cable by some illegal manufacturers. This illegal conduct i
  • Response
    What's the difference between a Chronograph and a Chronometer? A Chronograph cartier ring prices singapore refers to a watch,cartier ring prices singapo cartier love necklace pink gold re, which offers a stopwatch. It may have 2 or 3 different registers. Some quartz chronographs will time tenths of a second. Yo cartier ...
  • Response
    Response: 雨伞
    传说鲁班妻子云氏也是一位巧匠。《玉屑》上还记述,她是雨伞的发明者,第一把雨伞就是她送给丈夫出门给人家盖房屋时用的。 "伞"字早有出现,她大 雨伞 概是造出了能撑合的伞. 是谁 雨伞 发明的雨伞?对这个问题一直众说纷芸。有的说,埃及人最早使用雨伞,早在公元前1200年,埃及的贵族们外出旅游时常常要奴隶为他们太阳伞。罗马人用伞遮挡地中海地区 雨伞的阳光。在中国,伞是公元前1000年由鲁班的妻子发明的,伞被称作"能移动的房屋"。 在英国,在18世纪才开始使用雨伞。伞一度是女性的专用品,表示女人 雨伞 对爱情的
  • Response
    Response: 澳门赌场
    这是新建文章 1 澳门赌场 6.html,请修改添加正文内容。 ,澳门赌场; 澳门赌场 百家乐带给我的生活趣味 ,澳门赌场; 也许很多人都不知道百家乐是什么东西,但是在娱乐方面比较擅长的人都会晓得百家乐是什么。这是互联网时代一个非常好的娱乐场所,只要我们登陆到这一个网站站点,就可以在这上面得到很多线下得不到的乐趣。 ,澳门赌场 新建文章 12; 百家乐在上线之后就在整个互 百家乐 联网上得到了广大游戏玩家的支持,很多喜欢实地玩游戏的人也开始在
  • Response
    Response: ABS pipes
    In an interview with the production manager and beautiful animal food Co., ABS pipes Wen Xiaoyong to the power company on the one hand, the "prophetic vision" PVC tubes be profuse in praise. He told reporters, because they do not understand the power, in the enterprise PVC hoses
  • Response
    Response: 澳门百家乐
    ,百家 百家乐 澳门赌场 617中场开球在北京市中国人民大学足 乐 澳门赌场 617中场开球在北京市中国人民大学足下载附件 ,澳门赌场 新建文章 1;保存到相册 下载附件 ...
  • Response
    Response: tt娱乐城
      有着“中国好学姐”之称的周玥经常演唱一些经典歌曲,百家乐,成为了 百家乐 治愈系萌物,澳门赌场 [已解决] 蓝色理想论坛的title是怎 澳门赌场 [已解决] 蓝色理想论坛的title是怎么写的谁 么写的谁。清纯可人的装扮化身疗伤女神,素颜照甜美可爱传递正能量,百家乐代理 澳门赌场 Your hand feels cold_4。灰色针织衫搭配白色领带T恤,是不是很有欧美学院风呢,澳门赌场 澳门赌场 今后中国企业遇到类似情况时IDC通过其全_1?搭配红色宽下摆短裙与黑色 百家乐代理 澳门赌场 Your hand feels cold_4 裤袜,清新女神吸睛指数破表。
  • Response
    Mos pandora charms bracelets t golfers longing avow that fashion does h pandora charms sale ave something to do with their golf game. However,pandora charms bracelets, looking good does never always average you will activity well merely while you feel confident,p cheap pandora charms sale andora charms sale, you ambition d ...
  • Response
    Today,cheap pandora charms cheap pandora charms , Nike Company's Asi cheap pandora charms an biggest experience mart longing be officially opened among Shanghai Huaihai road's happening area In the mart some facilities longing be set up, such because free courses as experi pandora charms sale ence plus training,pl
  • Response
    Response: chanel replica
    chanel replica handbag chanel replica s
  • Response
    篇一:生活中的亮点 生活中的亮点无处不在,它们就像一株株幽香可儿的花,绽放在城市的每一个角落大街、冷巷、商铺....让我们睁开那双擅长发现的 5、爱的出发点不一定是身体 慧眼,去找找它们吧! 5、爱的出发点不一定是身体 镜头一:[大街里]一只不幸的流离猫正在 你们知道这是为什么吗 没精打采地走着,一阵阵寒风的来袭使它瑟瑟抖动。它那本来雪白的毛曾经酿成了灰色,原本炯炯有神的眼睛也落空了神彩。走过它身边的人,都顾着着急地赶路,没有注意到它。一会儿,一个年青的妈妈牵着孩子的手走来了。当孩子瞥见这只猫时,俄然,她挣脱妈妈的手,跑到猫的 听力下降有什么危害 身
  • Response
    の長い天然痘は、両親に自分の手が、どうしますか,ロレッ ロレックス スーパーコピー クス スーパーコピー 持久の戦に天然痘私は徹底的に崩壊しましたから、どんな事もそんなに嫌になって スーパーコピー時計 たから、何もない私にこんな困った.は天然痘この事は私は毎日しかめっ面、苦しみがひどく恨みが深いの様子が!実は以前私も元気で明るい、会社の部下にも特別な温和で、しかし以来の長い天然痘の後、いつもややもすれば配下の者に対して怒って、身の回りの友達も珍 http://fukuchin.com/cgi-bin/custombbs.cgi/hGSsvIMej/ しい私は笑って、さらに彼らと一緒に出てぶらぶらしなかった.実は私もこのようにしたくなくて、本当に
  • Response
    网络电话项目招商加盟! VOIP-OEM 加盟惠捷通网络电话-拥有自己的 VOIP 产品平台,门槛低、投资小,来自www.hjtok.com惠捷通网络电话,支持任意定制OEM外观、ios/android/多系统支持、多家成功品牌案例、多级 网络电话 代理商运营扩展,网络电话oem解决方案,虚拟运营方案,是中国最好的网络电话软件。详情联系:13692282319黎先生 VOIP-API接口、SDK定制 惠捷通平台VoIP网络通话开发简单,开发者在惠捷通平台接入网络电话功能,就可使 www.hjtok.com 用

Reader Comments (1)

A simple entry in the system can be made to keep the depreciation record updated. Depreciation reports too provide useful information to owners. It helps the corporation to plan for the repair, maintenance and replacements of common assets or property.

January 2, 2013 | Unregistered CommenterDepreciation report

PostPost a New Comment

Enter your information below to add a new comment.

My response is on my own website »
Author Email (optional):
Author URL (optional):
Post:
 
Some HTML allowed: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <code> <em> <i> <strike> <strong>